Paycheck Calculator · Car Insurance Cost · Mortgage Payment

Average Car Insurance Cost in New Mexico (2023)

By Atlas by RapidTool · Updated

Average car insurance cost in New Mexico is the typical annual premium per insured vehicle for a policy with liability, collision and comprehensive coverage: about $1,301 per year (2023 NAIC data). That is 10% below the national average of $1,439 and ranks 21 of 50 states, highest first.

Key takeaways

Roughly $108 per month.

Highest and lowest average premiums

StateAverage annual premium
Florida$1,994
Louisiana$1,983
New York$1,896
North Dakota$961
Vermont$958
Maine$926

New Mexico vs nearby states

StateAverage annual premium
New Mexico$1,301
Arizona$1,505
Colorado$1,655
Texas$1,727
Oklahoma$1,324

How it works in New Mexico

This page shows the average annual auto insurance premium in New Mexico from NAIC data for 2023. Your own price depends on age, driving record, vehicle, ZIP code and coverage. NAIC cautions that state averages reflect different coverage choices, vehicle values and state laws, so compare states with care.

What this estimate includes

Common questions

Why is my car insurance quote different from the New Mexico average?

Insurers price by driver, vehicle, location and coverage. A state average is a benchmark, not a quote.

How old is this car insurance data?

The latest NAIC report available covers 2023, so current premiums are likely different.

How can I pay less for car insurance?

Compare quotes from several insurers, ask about discounts and review your coverage levels.

Sources. NAIC (National Association of Insurance Commissioners) 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report, adopted December 2025: combined average premium per insured vehicle, 2023. Compiled from the sources above. Data last updated: 2026-10-05.

Estimates for planning only. See the disclaimer.

Keep exploring

Paycheck Calculator in New Mexico · Mortgage Payment in New Mexico · All New Mexico pages · Car Insurance Cost by state

Nearby states: Arizona · Colorado · Texas · Oklahoma

We use cookies for analytics. See our privacy policy.